Literature is a beautiful way of expressing ideas, emotions,
themes, messages, and stories in a way that can be universally understood and
is relatable. It allows the reader to become connected with a different world
and gain a different perspective. Reading a piece of literature should provoke
thoughts, imagination, questions, concerns, and many emotions for a reader. Literature
can show us what life was like at a certain time or place, without just giving
us facts, and can help us readers note the similarities and differences in our
society and character’s society. Calvino is right in defining and describing
literature in so many different ways because it is complex, and there is an
abundance of literature.
Ultimately, literature exists so that people can see
different perspectives on human nature, society, and the unknown worlds around
us. It is there to help us question our own beliefs and challenge what we
previously thought was true. While literature can be thought provoking, it can also
serve as enjoyment in helping one cope with the stresses of every day life,
serving as an outlet and escape that allows the person to think about different
things.
Response to Calvino’s Why
Read the Classics?
Calvino is right in describing many aspects of literature. He
frequently notes how one piece of literature can be interpreted in many
different ways. I agree with his suggestion that “we can never recommend enough
a first-hand reading of the text itself, avoiding as far as possible secondary
bibliography, commentaries, and other interpretations” (Calvino 5). It makes me
think of works of literature that are made into movies. Many people choose to
see a movie and then judge the book from what the movie was like, which is a
terrible thing to do. For example, I watched the movie of Pride and Prejudice before reading the book and went into the book
much more narrow-minded and with formulated opinions of each character. From
the book, I could see completely different sides of the characters and relate
much better to some of them. While people have produced films of classics such
as Romeo and Juliet, it does no
justice to the beautiful way in which Shakespeare writes and it cannot be
compared to the plays that he wrote. Literature and film are completely
different and it is much harder to interpret films in multiple different ways
since you are just watching the story take place.
In addition Calvino greatly discusses the importance of
rereading a classic so that one can gain more insight and discover new things
about the book that he or she didn’t pick up on before. I agree with this, but
I find that when people reread certain things over and over again, they start
to analyze the work more than they look at the big ideas and simple messages
being conveyed. Literature is a piece of work that authors spend countless
hours working on, and every detail is important. If one spends the time to
truly appreciate and understand the literature, it can become a classic that
will be valued for many years to come.
I liked the way you juxtaposed film and literature in your response. I agree that a film only allows for one interpretation, but that singular interpretation may give you a new perspective on the work. The filmmaker or director may have ideas differing from yours that you may not have originally noticed or been able to see in the text. The same happens each time a director puts on the same play. However, you are correct that it is better to read the book before the film or play instead of the other way around so that it offers you an additional perspective instead of the only one.
ReplyDeleteI recommend that you read Brave New World by Aldous Huxley. This fictional novel written in the 1930's is his interpretation of the society of the future. It is interesting how much his futuristic society reflects our culture today. It makes one realize how our world is moving in that direction. Also, I found the book quite enjoyable to read.
DeleteI really liked reading this; it was very interesting and insightful. I completely agree that films do very little justice to delineating the depth of works of literature but sometimes they aid visualization and understanding of the piece. Also, just like Lauren said, some films do bring out perspectives of the literature piece that you may not have discovered in the reading. In totality this was good.
ReplyDeleteAlso, Mrs. Seaman said we should recommend classics to each other. I would like to recommend "The Great Gatsby" by Scott Fitzgerald. For me, this book threw light upon the harshness of the people of the world. Quite recently the movie was released- I recommend that you watch the movie too.